Jackson, Mississippi: Mistrial Declared in Murder Case of Prominent LGBTQ+ Figure
In a significant courtroom development, a judge declared a mistrial on Wednesday in the murder trial of Sheldon “Timothy” Herrington Jr., who was accused of killing Jimmy “Jay” Lee, a well-known figure in the LGBTQ+ community at the University of Mississippi. The case has been closely followed since Lee’s disappearance in July 2022, a mystery that remains unresolved as his body has never been found.
What Happened
The jury deliberated for over nine and a half hours but could not reach a unanimous verdict. They had the option to find Herrington guilty of several charges, including capital murder, first-degree murder, and manslaughter, or to acquit him entirely. Circuit Judge Kelly Luther indicated that a new trial may need to be moved to a different venue to ensure fairness, as the jury comprised individuals from a separate county.
Who is Involved
Sheldon Herrington, 24, is currently free on bond but still faces serious charges, including capital murder stemming from an alleged kidnapping incident. Herrington showed little emotional response as he left the courtroom with family and legal representatives. The prosecution has stated that they will not pursue the death penalty, meaning Herrington could face life in prison if convicted at a future trial.
Where and When
The trial was held in Oxford, Mississippi, where both Herrington and Jimmy Lee attended the University of Mississippi. Lee, who was only 20 years old, was pursuing a master’s degree and was noted for his vibrant contributions to the community through fashion and drag performances. He vanished on July 8, 2022, prompting a police investigation that linked Herrington to the case.
Why the Mistrial?
During the court proceedings, conflicting testimonies and a lack of concrete evidence led to a deadlocked jury. The prosecution argued that Herrington had engaged in a sexual encounter with Lee that turned violent, prompting Lee to leave Herrington’s apartment. The prosecution presented evidence of text messages suggesting Herrington had lured Lee back under false pretenses.
District Attorney Ben Creekmore stated, “Tim Herrington lived a lie—he lied to Jay Lee to coax him over there, promising to do something with him.” On the other hand, Herrington’s attorney, Kevin Horan, argued that there was no definitive proof of Lee’s death without a body and claimed the text messages did not indicate that Herrington had manipulated Lee into returning to his apartment.
Key Evidence
Investigators provided compelling evidence during the trial, including electronic records that showed explicit messages exchanged between Herrington and Lee in the hours leading to Lee’s disappearance. Testimonies revealed that Herrington had searched online for information related to strangulation just before the timeline of Lee’s last known communications. Security footage captured him leaving the area where Lee’s vehicle was found abandoned.
The courtroom atmosphere was tense, with Herrington’s relatives sitting behind him and Lee’s family behind the prosecution. After the mistrial was declared, Judge Luther offered gratitude to the jurors for their service and acknowledged the difficulty of their task.
What Lies Ahead
With the mistrial concluded, discussions regarding a retrial are anticipated. Judge Luther will consult with both the prosecution and defense attorneys to determine the next steps, including potential scheduling of a new trial and possible adjustments to the venue. The outcome of this case remains uncertain, but the community is eager for resolution as questions surrounding Jimmy Lee’s disappearance and the circumstances leading to his tragic fate continue to loom large.
